Skip to content

Identity and reality in the modern Australian and ancient Jewish diasporas

Our family has been away from Australia for almost 3 years now. One of the funny things we’ve noticed about ourselves is how much our Australian identity is wrapped up in symbols and dreams that have little to do with reality. For example, this 1-minute ad for Tourism Australia–based on Les Murray’s poem, “The Dream of Wearing Shorts Forever”–brings a little tear to my eye:

H/T Wes.

But here’s the strange thing: even though this ad / poem expresses our Australian identity, it doesn’t express our Australian reality. Australia is, in reality, one of the most urbanised countries in the world. The vast majority of us huddle together in urban sprawl. The enormous paddocks, the river bends, the grassy forests, the kangaroos and the pristine islands have very little to do with the average daily experience of an Aussie. In fact, our own family is quintessentially urban. We prefer living in the bustle of town-houses, not in the empty vistas viewed from wide plank verandahs. Indeed, as a family we’re pathologically camping-averse–we’ll never hesitate to point out that 40 years of camping in the wilderness was God’s punishment for Israel’s rebellion.

But none of that matters. We’re Australian. No matter what our experience is; the kangaroos, the deserts, the river beds, the bush and (above all) the wearing of shorts define our identity. It’s who we are. And the longer we’re away from the reality, the more these dreams define our identity.

Which all leads me to make a point about the research I’ve been doing over the last 3 years. I’ve been looking at Jewish identity in the first-century Mediterranean Diaspora, especially as it relates to the apostle Paul. I’ve been asking what symbols define “Jewishness” for Paul and his contemporaries, and what this has to do with Paul’s explicit references to Jewishness in his letters. And I’ve realised that in answering this question, purely historical study can only get me so far. Historians like to dig around to try to discover the historical “reality” behind the texts. But I’ve discovered that if you really understand what makes ancient Jews tick, you also need to read their texts, sympathetically. You need to read the Scriptures, especially, because it’s the Scriptures that provide the symbols, the stories, and the grand narrative that defines what it means for Jews to be Jews. And even if these symbols and stories don’t always match up to what life was “actually like” on the ground for first-century Jews, that doesn’t necessarily matter. Scriptural identity is often more important than daily reality.

For Paul, the thing that defines Jewish identity above all is possessing and knowing God’s special revelation in the Scriptures of Israel (especially the Law of Moses). In this, he agrees with Josephus and Philo:

[F]or all men are eager to preserve their own customs and laws, and the Jewish nation above all others; for looking upon their laws as oracles directly given to them by God himself, and having been instructed in this doctrine from their very earliest infancy they bear in their souls the images of the commandments contained in these laws as sacred; […] and they admit such foreigners as are disposed to honour and worship them, to do so no less than their own native fellow citizens. (Philo, Legatio ad Gaium 210–211 [Yonge])

He [i.e. Moses] left no pretext for ignorance, but instituted the law as the finest and most essential teaching-material; so that it would be heard not just once or twice or a number of times, he ordered that every seven days they should abandon their other activities and gather to hear the law, and to learn it thoroughly and in detail. That is something that all [other] legislators seem to have neglected. (Josephus, Against Apion 2.175 [tr. Barclay, 2007])

Are Josephus and Philo describing a historical “reality” here? It’s unlikely that every single Jew knew the law “thoroughly and in detail”. But that doesn’t matter. The point is that God’s revelation in the law defines Jewish identity. Just as modern Aussie identity is defined by wearing shorts, ancient Jewish identity is defined by possessing, knowing, learning and honouring God’s revelation in the Scriptures, especially the Law of Moses.

I’ve argued, on the basis of Paul’s letters, that Paul agrees with his contemporaries that Jewish identity is caught up directly with God’s revelation in the Scriptures. However, Paul utterly rejects any assumption that possessing the law will lead to obedience (and therefore to salvation) in any straightforward way. For many of Paul’s Jewish opponents, the divine Jewish calling (or “vocation”) consisted primarily in keeping and teaching the precepts of the Law of Moses as an exemplary witness to God’s power and wisdom. For Paul, however, the divine Jewish vocation consisted primarily in preaching the gospel of Jesus Christ, as the fulfilment of the Law of Moses, to the Gentiles.

Published inBiblical theologyEpistemologyHouse of WindsorJustificationPaulRevelationRomans

House of Windsor Editing Services

Bronwyn Windsor - House of Windsor Editing and Proofreading Services

Are you writing a thesis, book, academic article, resource, theological monograph, or anything else?

Bronwyn Windsor offers professional editing and proofreading services for writers. Press here to find out more: House of Windsor Editing Services

Publications by Lionel Windsor:

  • Lift Your Eyes: Reflections on Ephesians

All posts

Recent blog posts

  • Photo by Joseph d'Mello on UnsplashPreaching the Pastoral Epistles
    A one-hour audio seminar with principles and ideas for preaching the biblical books 1 Timothy, 2 Timothy and Titus ("Pastoral Epistles")
  • A Crash Course in Romans: Livestream
    Here's a <90 minute "Crash Course in Romans" I'm running on Monday evening 1 Feb 2021. It's aimed at leaders and any interested members of my church St Augustine's Neutral Bay and Church by the Bridge Kirribilli. Anyone is welcome to watch the livestream.
  • Photo by Dmitry Ratushny on UnsplashWhat’s wrong with the world? Is there hope? (Ephesians)
    Guilt, weakness, spiritual slavery, prejudice, arrogance, tribalism, conflict, war, victimhood, persecution, pain, suffering, futility, ignorance, lying, deceit, anger, theft, greed, pornography, sexual sin, darkness, fear, drunkenness, substance abuse, domestic abuse, workplace abuse, spiritual powers... In Paul's letter to the Ephesians, he says many things about the problems we face in this world. He also gives us wonderful reasons to find life, hope and healing in Jesus Christ. Along the way, he provides practical teachings about how to respond and live together.
  • What does Ephesians say about reconciliation?
    We humans are not very good at living up close with others. This is especially true when we have a history of conflict with those others. Reconciliation isn't easy. No matter how much you might want healing, it’s hardly ever a matter of just everybody getting on and pretending the hurts didn’t happen. In Paul's letter to the Ephesians, he says some very important, fundamental things about peace and reconciliation, and gives many other very practical teachings about how to live together in light of these truths.
  • Lift Your Eyes: Reflections on EphesiansLift Your Eyes – How it works
    Lift Your Eyes: Reflections on Ephesians. Here's a video where I explain how the free online resource works.
  • Review: The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self by Carl Trueman
    I need to understand the people around me, so I can live for the gospel among them and speak the gospel to them. To do that, I need to understand the people around me. That's where Carl Trueman's book is so incredibly valuable.
  • What does Ephesians say about church?
    There are so many ideas about what the church is should be. How do we navigate them all? Here are ten key reflections from Ephesians.
  • Reading Ephesians & Colossians After Supersessionism (Cover image)Supersessionism and the New Perspective
    Here are my views on the issue of the New Perspective and Supersessionism, in light of a debate in the Harvard Theological Review.
  • The powerful Christian life: according to Ephesians
    What do we do when we feel weak in the face of powerful people? Here are seven key reflections on power from Ephesians.
  • Liturgy Song – Moore College Revue 2020
    Here's a tribute to our online chapel experience in mid-2020 at Moore College, in the full spirit of parody. I wrote it for our Moore College Revue, and had much fun performing it with Jordan Smith and Monique New.

On this site

All content copyright Lionel Windsor